How to Choose Your First Pickleball Paddle Without Crying

How to Choose Your First Pickleball Paddle Without Crying

So, you’ve decided to take the plunge into the world of pickleball. Congratulations! You’re about to join a community that’s equal parts competitive athletes, social butterflies, and retirees who will absolutely destroy you with their dinks. But before you can step onto the court and shout “kitchen!” with confidence, you need to pick your most important piece of equipment: the paddle.

 


Now, if you’ve ever wandered into a sporting goods store or browsed online for a pickleball paddle, you might have been hit with a wave of confusion. Why are there so many options? What’s the difference between graphite and fiberglass? And why is there a paddle that costs more than your monthly car payment?


Don’t worry. Choosing your first paddle doesn’t have to be a tear-filled odyssey of indecision. Let’s break it down, step by step, with just enough humor to keep you from hurling your computer out the window.


Step 1: Know Your Budget (Because Paddles Ain’t Free)


First things first—how much do you want to spend? Pickleball paddles range from $30 (your basic entry-level models) to $300 (the high-tech ones that make you feel like a Jedi).


For your first paddle, aim for something in the $50–$100 range. It’s the sweet spot where you’ll get a decent paddle without needing to take out a second mortgage. Save the $200 paddle for when you’ve mastered the art of the dink and feel ready to intimidate your opponents with both your skills and your spending power.


Step 2: Weight Matters (No, Not Your Weight—The Paddle’s)


Pickleball paddles come in three weight categories:

Lightweight (7.0–7.5 oz): Great for quick reactions and control. Perfect if you like finessing your way to victory or if the idea of swinging something heavier makes your arms tired just thinking about it.

Midweight (7.6–8.4 oz): The Goldilocks option—not too heavy, not too light. Most players start here because it offers a nice balance of power and control.

Heavyweight (8.5 oz+): These paddles pack a punch and are ideal for players who enjoy smashing the ball so hard that their opponents question their life choices.


Pro Tip: If you’re unsure, go midweight. It’s like ordering a medium pizza—it’s hard to go wrong.


Step 3: Material World (Graphite, Fiberglass, and Carbon Fiber, Oh My!)


Pickleball paddles come in different materials, and each one has its own vibe:

1. Graphite: Lightweight and precise, it’s perfect for players who value control and finesse. If you’re planning to become a dinking master, graphite is your jam.

2. Fiberglass (Composite): Offers more power while still being versatile. It’s a great choice if you want to mix finesse with the occasional smash.

3. Carbon Fiber: The top-tier option. It’s durable, offers incredible control, and will definitely make you look like you know what you’re doing (even if you don’t).


Pro Tip: Don’t get too hung up on the material for your first paddle. Any option will work fine as long as it doesn’t feel like a brick in your hand.


Step 4: The Grip (Hold on Tight)


The grip is the part of the paddle you’ll be holding during every shot, so it needs to feel comfortable. Pickleball grips come in different sizes, ranging from 4 inches to 4.5 inches in circumference.

If you have small hands, go for a smaller grip (around 4 inches).

If you have larger hands, opt for a bigger grip (4.25–4.5 inches).

If you’re somewhere in between, don’t panic. You can always add an overgrip to adjust the size.


Pro Tip: If your hand cramps up during play, your grip is too small. If your paddle flies out of your hand mid-smash, it’s too big.


Step 5: The Shape (Yes, It Matters)


Paddles come in different shapes, but for your first one, stick to the classic widebody shape. It has a larger sweet spot (the magical area where the ball feels amazing when you hit it), making it more forgiving for beginners.


Once you’ve leveled up, you can experiment with elongated paddles for more reach or teardrop-shaped paddles for extra control. But for now, widebody is your best friend.


Step 6: Test It Out (If Possible)


If you have the chance to try paddles before buying, do it. Many pickleball courts have demo paddles you can borrow, or you can ask a friend to let you test theirs. Just don’t blame their paddle when you inevitably hit the ball into the net—that’s on you.


Step 7: Ignore the Hype (Sort Of)


Yes, there are paddles with fancy marketing terms like “vortex spin technology” or “hyper-grip dynamics.” And while those features can be cool, they’re not necessary for a beginner. Focus on finding a paddle that feels good in your hand and suits your playing style.


Save the high-tech paddles for when you’re ready to wow the crowd with your Erne shots and third-shot drops.


Step 8: Embrace Your Paddle (Even If It’s Not Perfect)


Here’s the thing: no matter which paddle you choose, it won’t turn you into a pickleball legend overnight. You’ll miss shots, lose games, and occasionally wonder if you bought the wrong paddle. That’s all part of the learning process.


The good news? Your first paddle is just the beginning. As you improve, you’ll figure out what you like and what you don’t, and you can always upgrade later.


Final Thoughts: You’ve Got This!


Choosing your first pickleball paddle might feel overwhelming, but it doesn’t have to be. Stick to your budget, pick a weight and material that feels good, and don’t overthink it. At the end of the day, it’s not the paddle that wins games—it’s the player holding it.


So grab a paddle, hit the court, and remember: the real goal is to have fun (and maybe smack a few dinks while you’re at it). Good luck, and welcome to the wonderful world of pickleball!

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.